Welcome
Username or Email:

Password:


Missing Code




[ ]
[ ]
Online
  • Guests: 91
  • Members: 0
  • Newest Member: omjtest
  • Most ever online: 396
    Guests: 396, Members: 0 on 12 Jan : 12:51
Members Birthdays:
One birthday today, congrats!
RateReducer (35)


Next birthdays
11/01 RateReducer (35)
11/02 Download (31)
11/02 ScottH (37)
Contact
If you need assistance, please send an email to forum at 4hv dot org. To ensure your email is not marked as spam, please include the phrase "4hv help" in the subject line. You can also find assistance via IRC, at irc.shadowworld.net, room #hvcomm.
Support 4hv.org!
Donate:
4hv.org is hosted on a dedicated server. Unfortunately, this server costs and we rely on the help of site members to keep 4hv.org running. Please consider donating. We will place your name on the thanks list and you'll be helping to keep 4hv.org alive and free for everyone. Members whose names appear in red bold have donated recently. Green bold denotes those who have recently donated to keep the server carbon neutral.


Special Thanks To:
  • Aaron Holmes
  • Aaron Wheeler
  • Adam Horden
  • Alan Scrimgeour
  • Andre
  • Andrew Haynes
  • Anonymous000
  • asabase
  • Austin Weil
  • barney
  • Barry
  • Bert Hickman
  • Bill Kukowski
  • Blitzorn
  • Brandon Paradelas
  • Bruce Bowling
  • BubeeMike
  • Byong Park
  • Cesiumsponge
  • Chris F.
  • Chris Hooper
  • Corey Worthington
  • Derek Woodroffe
  • Dalus
  • Dan Strother
  • Daniel Davis
  • Daniel Uhrenholt
  • datasheetarchive
  • Dave Billington
  • Dave Marshall
  • David F.
  • Dennis Rogers
  • drelectrix
  • Dr. John Gudenas
  • Dr. Spark
  • E.TexasTesla
  • eastvoltresearch
  • Eirik Taylor
  • Erik Dyakov
  • Erlend^SE
  • Finn Hammer
  • Firebug24k
  • GalliumMan
  • Gary Peterson
  • George Slade
  • GhostNull
  • Gordon Mcknight
  • Graham Armitage
  • Grant
  • GreySoul
  • Henry H
  • IamSmooth
  • In memory of Leo Powning
  • Jacob Cash
  • James Howells
  • James Pawson
  • Jeff Greenfield
  • Jeff Thomas
  • Jesse Frost
  • Jim Mitchell
  • jlr134
  • Joe Mastroianni
  • John Forcina
  • John Oberg
  • John Willcutt
  • Jon Newcomb
  • klugesmith
  • Leslie Wright
  • Lutz Hoffman
  • Mads Barnkob
  • Martin King
  • Mats Karlsson
  • Matt Gibson
  • Matthew Guidry
  • mbd
  • Michael D'Angelo
  • Mikkel
  • mileswaldron
  • mister_rf
  • Neil Foster
  • Nick de Smith
  • Nick Soroka
  • nicklenorp
  • Nik
  • Norman Stanley
  • Patrick Coleman
  • Paul Brodie
  • Paul Jordan
  • Paul Montgomery
  • Ped
  • Peter Krogen
  • Peter Terren
  • PhilGood
  • Richard Feldman
  • Robert Bush
  • Royce Bailey
  • Scott Fusare
  • Scott Newman
  • smiffy
  • Stella
  • Steven Busic
  • Steve Conner
  • Steve Jones
  • Steve Ward
  • Sulaiman
  • Thomas Coyle
  • Thomas A. Wallace
  • Thomas W
  • Timo
  • Torch
  • Ulf Jonsson
  • vasil
  • Vaxian
  • vladi mazzilli
  • wastehl
  • Weston
  • William Kim
  • William N.
  • William Stehl
  • Wesley Venis
The aforementioned have contributed financially to the continuing triumph of 4hv.org. They are deserving of my most heartfelt thanks.
Forums
4hv.org :: Forums :: General Chatting
« Previous topic | Next topic »   

Who was more important Edison or Tesla?

1 2 3 4 
Move Thread LAN_403
Download
Mon Mar 05 2007, 06:50AM Print
Download Registered Member #561 Joined: Sat Mar 03 2007, 02:46AM
Location: Adelaide Australia
Posts: 230
Who do you think was more important, Edison or Tesla?
i will have to go with Tesla
Back to top
GreySoul
Mon Mar 05 2007, 07:28AM
GreySoul Registered Member #546 Joined: Fri Feb 23 2007, 11:43PM
Location: Albuquerque, NM
Posts: 239
I bet Batman could beat up Spiderman.

Seriously tho.... I'd go with tesla as well if for no other reason than he was far more photogenic than Edison.

Oh, and because my dream may come true: I've always wanted to test drive a Tesla Motors electric super car... and now they're going to be built in my back yard.

yay

-Doug
Back to top
Myke
Mon Mar 05 2007, 02:04PM
Myke Registered Member #540 Joined: Mon Feb 19 2007, 07:49PM
Location: MIT
Posts: 969
Tesla. I think somebody else invented the lightbulb then edison just improved on it.
Back to top
Zum Beispiel
Mon Mar 05 2007, 04:49PM
Zum Beispiel Registered Member #514 Joined: Sun Feb 11 2007, 12:27AM
Location: Somewhere in Pirkanmaa, Finland
Posts: 295
This is sort of an odd guestion. It's like asking if Coke is better than Pepsi (Coke is better wink ).

If I had to choose I'd have to go with Tesla. He made numerous inventions like the polyphase system and radio control, that are still in use to this day. (and the tesla coils that we all love so much wink ).

Also Edison wanted to use direct current for mains power, which was just... stupid.
Back to top
Steve Conner
Mon Mar 05 2007, 04:58PM
Steve Conner Registered Member #30 Joined: Fri Feb 03 2006, 10:52AM
Location: Glasgow, Scotland
Posts: 6706
Using DC for mains power seems dumb now, but at the time, not many people really knew better. Tesla and Westinghouse did know better, of course, and the rest is history.

I'm sure in 2100 people will look back and say "They wanted to use TCP/IP for the global nervous system? That's just... stupid"
Back to top
Madgyver
Mon Mar 05 2007, 05:20PM
Madgyver Registered Member #177 Joined: Wed Feb 15 2006, 02:16PM
Location: Munich, Germany
Posts: 214
GreySoul wrote ...

I bet Batman could beat up Spiderman.

Yeah, but Green Latern would smash them both. tongue

In my Opinion, none of them is more important. I have no idea if all this Edison/Tesla competition thing is real or just BS, but if it is real, then by competing with each other both of them were challenged to invent more and faster.
Back to top
Simon
Mon Mar 05 2007, 11:28PM
Simon Registered Member #32 Joined: Sat Feb 04 2006, 08:58AM
Location: Australia
Posts: 549
I tend to respect Tesla more. Edison seems to be a brilliant tinkerer and businessman and not much else. Tesla was the archetypal genius.

Edison did produce a lot of important stuff. (And, no, he did not invent the lightbulb, he tweaked the lightbulb into a profitable product. Sort of like how Galileo improved rather than invented the telescope.)
Back to top
...
Tue Mar 06 2007, 05:01AM
... Registered Member #56 Joined: Thu Feb 09 2006, 05:02AM
Location: Southern Califorina, USA
Posts: 2445
I would go for Tesla, because IMHO without his AC contributions edisons dc grid would have died out and we would still be living in the dark (well, unless someone came up with some even better system)
Back to top
Chris
Tue Mar 06 2007, 09:12AM
Chris Registered Member #8 Joined: Thu Feb 02 2006, 04:34AM
Location: Harlowton, MT, United States
Posts: 214
I agree on Tesla. I see it's pretty much unanimous here for him, and indeed the facts speak for themselves. Edison relied on trial and error and previous ideas almost exclusively in his work, and was mainly a shrewd businessman. He was impatient by nature, and his character was inhospitable to his colleagues as well. While he was innovative enough to invent, he did it primarily as an opportunity for business. Tesla was the opposite in many regards, but thought outside the box and invented our AC power grid, AC induction motors that we use today, made extensive contributions to the field of radio, did groundbreaking work in LC resonance, and thereby laid the foundation for much of our modern technology. Like many brilliant minds, society did not condone his type and he eventually turned more or less a madman, with all the mystery thereto assigned.

Isn't it interesting how through all this the one with the most recognition and fame is Edison? Ask anyone on the street, and they have probably never heard of Tesla, but remember being tought in school of Edison's greatness. Isn't it interesting how Edison was so much more compatible with society's mindset that he rose to fame while Tesla's accoplishments and contributions are only recognized in obscure scientific communities such as this? Most people think Edison was the father of modern electricity because the system is set up to breed Edisons and shun Teslas.
Back to top
AndrewM
Tue Mar 06 2007, 03:40PM
AndrewM Registered Member #49 Joined: Thu Feb 09 2006, 04:05AM
Location: Bigass Pile of Penguins
Posts: 362
Chris wrote ...

I agree on Tesla. I see it's pretty much unanimous here for him, and indeed the facts speak for themselves. Edison relied on trial and error and previous ideas almost exclusively in his work, and was mainly a shrewd businessman. He was impatient by nature, and his character was inhospitable to his colleagues as well. While he was innovative enough to invent, he did it primarily as an opportunity for business. Tesla was the opposite in many regards, but thought outside the box and invented our AC power grid, AC induction motors that we use today, made extensive contributions to the field of radio, did groundbreaking work in LC resonance, and thereby laid the foundation for much of our modern technology. Like many brilliant minds, society did not condone his type and he eventually turned more or less a madman, with all the mystery thereto assigned.

Isn't it interesting how through all this the one with the most recognition and fame is Edison? Ask anyone on the street, and they have probably never heard of Tesla, but remember being tought in school of Edison's greatness. Isn't it interesting how Edison was so much more compatible with society's mindset that he rose to fame while Tesla's accoplishments and contributions are only recognized in obscure scientific communities such as this? Most people think Edison was the father of modern electricity because the system is set up to breed Edisons and shun Teslas.

You mean to say there is no virtue in the way Edison could "play the game"? Everything you just said can be reworded in favor of Edison, it all depends on your point of view. Conformational bias, anyone:

I agree on Edison. I see it's pretty much unanimous here for him, and indeed the facts speak for themselves. Edison relied on heritage and previous ideas extensively in his work, and was a shrewd businessman. He was determined and focused, and demanded the best from his colleagues as well. He used his capacity for invention as a business opportunity. Tesla was the opposite in many regards, but thought outside the box and invented our AC power grid, AC induction motors that we use today, made extensive contributions to the field of radio, did groundbreaking work in LC resonance, and thereby laid the foundation for much of our modern technology. However, unlike Edison, he was completely unable to learn to work within the boundaries of society, and turned more or less a madman, with all the mystery thereto assigned.

It is no suprise that the one with the most recognition and fame is Edison. Ask anyone on the street, and they have probably never heard of Tesla, but remember being tought in school of Edison's greatness. Clearly it takes more than Edison's clever mind to be compatible with society's mindset. That he he rose to fame while Tesla's accoplishments and contributions are only recognized in obscure scientific communities such as this pays tribute to the fact that being smart isn't enough, one must be well spoken, charistmatic, and elloquent as well. Edison is remembered as the father of modern electricity because he was able to work electricity as well as the system, and Tesla sucked at the latter.
Back to top
1 2 3 4 

Moderator(s): Chris Russell, Noelle, Alex, Tesladownunder, Dave Marshall, Dave Billington, Bjørn, Steve Conner, Wolfram, Kizmo, Mads Barnkob

Go to:

Powered by e107 Forum System
 
Legal Information
This site is powered by e107, which is released under the GNU GPL License. All work on this site, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.5 License. By submitting any information to this site, you agree that anything submitted will be so licensed. Please read our Disclaimer and Policies page for information on your rights and responsibilities regarding this site.